
THE GREEN
FACTS
The Sustainable Packaging Coalition Bio-Additive Webinar
Largest resin manufacturers conclude biodegradable additives don’t work as advertised
Additives added to polyethylene for the express purpose of rendering the polyethylene article as ‘biodegradable’ are controversial. These additive technologies (also known as degradable, oxo-degradable, oxo-biodegradable, photo-degradable, or photo-oxo-degradable) have been around for decades and are based on chemistries that either: 1) promote the oxidative degradation of the polymer in the presence of oxygen and either heat or sunlight; or 2) are composed of materials that are readily biodegradable (e.g. starch or cellulose) that are easily broken down in the environment, leaving the polyethylene largely intact. To the best of our knowledge, neither technology is capable of fully degrading the polymer and relies on the partially degraded plastic article that results from these processes to be subsequently degraded by microbes present in the environment, thus rendering the article ‘biodegradable’.
However, in most cases, the partially degraded polymer fragments are not decomposed to an extent that they can be sufficiently consumed by microbes. The resulting plastic fragments (i.e., microplastics) persist and often lead to other detrimental impacts to the environment, that in some cases, are more worrisome than the original plastic article itself. Furthermore, the use of these additives does not make them compatible with commercial composting and can compromise the mechanical recyclability of the plastic article, meaning that the only viable disposal method is to landfill it.
NOVA Chemical’s Additives Technology team therefore recommends that any organization considering use of these additives carefully examine the provided technical information and scrutinize the claims of biodegradation, to determine if these claims are aligned with their sustainability objectives. Several notable organizations share similar opinions, and the following are links to relevant webpages discussing the controversy surrounding additive technologies for degradable polyethylene:
NEW POST:
"SPC’s POSITION STATEMENT ON ‘BIODEGRADABLE’ PACKAGING"
A Paper by the Sustainable Packaging Coalition
"Oxo Statement"
A Paper by New Plastics Economy
"US Plastics Pact’s list of problematic plastics draws concern from industry"
An Article by Recycling Today
"Biodegradable Plastics and Marine Litter: Misconceptions, concerns and impacts on marine environments"
A Paper from the UN Environment Programme
“Background on Biodegradable Additives"
A Fact Sheet from the Biodegradable Products Institute
“Oxo-Degradable Plastics: So-called ‘oxo-biodegradables’ and other additive-mediated plastics are not bioplastics"
An Article by European Bioplastics
“Biodegradability Additives Cannot Alleviate Ocean Plastic Pollution"
An Article by the Sustainable Packaging Coalition
ABOUT THIS FEATURE WEBINAR
The SPC and other organizations such as the Ellen MacArthur Foundation and Association of Plastics Recyclers have had position statements against the use of biodegradability additives for over five years now. Yet in recent years, there has been an increase in products claiming to have new biodegradability properties such as “bio-assimilation.” What are these new claims, and should they be trusted? How do you screen claims to “perform the smell test” on whether these products really are different from older versions of biodegradable additives? Learn from academic and legal experts and companies navigating these claims.
Learn from world-changing thinkers and innovators
HERE ARE THE CLIFF NOTES:
Most bioplastics require an industrial composting facility in order to actually break down quickly and less harmfully. These plastics, which generally have some phrase similar to “industrially compostable” are only compostable in industrial composting facilities.
02:09 – 15:55: Response on Additive w/Carbon Carbon - Dr.Ramani Narayan, Biobased Material Research Group, Michigan State University.
25:36, 25:46, 26:06: Pictures of bio-additive film burial trial – Dr.Refael Auras, School of Packaging, MSU.
30:42: ASTM Standards - Rob Flores, Berry
37:42: What is the value for bio-additive?
43:30: Microplastics
44:05: Bio-additive explanation; is it bad and education question.
45:16: Rob Flores response to same question.
47:04: Additive is not the enemy.
49:47 – 50:55: Guidance to consumers.
SPEAKERS